Privacy News Highlights
24 November—01
December 2005
Contents:
US – Inspector
General: Biometrics Could Reduce Fraud, Improve Identity Verification
UK – Government Officials Reveal Anti-Crime Wish List
BC – Loukidelis Re-appointed as BC’s
Information and Privacy Commissioner
CA – Proposed Merger of Privacy,
Information Czars a Mistake
CA – Canada Passes Do Not Call Legislation
CA – Ottawa To Allocate $110 Million for
Big-City Transit Security
WW – Surveys Show Online Shoppers Fear ID Theft
CA – Achats en ligne : les Canadiens plus
craintifs que les Américains
UK – Report: E-Gov Becomes T-Gov
US – Internet Providers Better at Stopping Spam, FTC Says
EU – EU Committee Approves Storage of Internet Usage
UK – Patient Worries over e-Records
US – Disk Encryption Technology Integrated in U.S.
Department of State Pilot Project
EU – Review of EU Regulatory Framework for Electronic
Communications and Services
EU – Annul Passenger Data Decisions, says Advocate
General
UK – Users Flood ‘Most Wanted’ Website
EU – Clock Ticking for EU Administration’s Compliance
with Data Protection
EU –
Commission Proposes Changes to JLS Databases
CA – Bank Warns Against Identity Theft
Miscues
ON – Security Worries Hamper Wireless
Health-Care Plans
WW – Forecast: ID Theft by Insiders to Grow Dramatically
in '06
UK – ID Card Bill Powers Need More Scrutiny, says Select
Committee
UK – Forged ID Cards Won’t Work, Insists Government
EU – Music Industry Seeks Access to Private Data to Fight
Piracy
US – Ct. Lawmakers Announce Bill to Limit Access to
Electronic Scanners
UN – UN Assembly Adopts E-Contracting Convention
WW – Cybercrime Outpaces Drug Trafficking, Expert Says
US – Crooks Covet Justice Databases
US – 50 US States Introduced Outsourcing Legislation
US – GAO Auditors: Data Lacking on Impact of Offshoring
on Consumer Privacy
US – Cybercrime Treaty Seen as Civil Liberties Threat
WW – Amazon Wish Lists Expose Kids
AU – Privacy Commissioner: Delays for Privacy
Investigations
NZ – Privacy Commissioner: Privacy Complaints Have
Decreased
CA – Study: Consumer Fears High About ID
Theft
WW – Microsoft Corp. Offers Free Test Version of Security
Service Test
WW – Merchants Jump
on Visa's Free Security Service
WW – Big Brother Monitor Sniffs Out Internal Fraud
US – Federal Government Employees Slated To Receive New
ID Cards Next Year
CA – Transport Canada plan could put the
brakes on your right to drive
US – Cell Phone Companies to Develop Wireless 411
Directory
US – NC Businesses Must Destroy Documents Containing
Personal Data under New Law
The IG for the Department of Homeland Security
recommends that the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services agency should use
biometrics to verify identities. The report concludes that the system used to
verify identities of people applying for
The Home Office is seeking increased use of biometrics
and RFID tracking to fight crime. The government is planning increased use of
biometrics to verify identities. The Home Office plans to create a “Biometric
Center of Excellence” to explore other uses for the technology. [Source]
BC’s Information and Privacy Commissioner, David
Loukidelis, was appointed for a second six-year term. Members of a Special
Committee of the Legislature unanimously recommended that the House reappoint Loukidelis.
In its deliberations, members of the Committee considered it appropriate to
interview Mr. Loukidelis before deciding whether or not to undertake an open
competition. As a result of their interview and their assessment of the
Commissioner’s performance during his first term, it was clear to the Committee
that a further search was unlikely to result in a more accomplished applicant. A
September 2005 amendment to the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy
Act removed a provision limiting a Commissioner to serving only one six-year
term. The amendment brought the Act into line with the statutes governing the
other statutory officers in
Merging the offices of the information and privacy
watchdogs would take some of the bite out of their roles, warns a federally
commissioned report. Former Supreme Court justice Gerard La Forest urged the
federal government to focus instead on making information and privacy laws work
better for the public. The information commissioner is an ombudsman for
Canadians who request files under the federal access law, while the privacy
commissioner handles complaints about abuses of personal information. The appointment
of a single commissioner to both offices “would likely have a detrimental
impact” on the policy aims of the access and privacy laws, Mr. La Forest’s
report says. Combining the functions would not save much money and could leave
one commissioner with too much work, he said. Mr. La Forest calls on the
government to “do much more” to foster compliance with information and privacy
obligations. He says the government should:
- Make it clear that information should be provided to
requesters unless there is a compelling reason not to do so;
- Develop better information management systems;
- Provide incentives for complying with the law. [Source] [Coverage]
Bill C-37, the do-not-call bill, is now law in
The federal government will spend $110 million on
improving transit security in the country's six largest cities, announcved Transport
Minister Jean Lapierre's last week. The bulk of the money will go to
Lapierre
also announced $29.1 million will be distributed among 101 ports and marine
facilities for surveillance equipment, dockside and perimeter security,
communications equipment and training. He said the new security started with
aviation. Next came ports. Now the focus is on mass transit. [Source]
Two recent surveys of U.S. Internet users indicate
that online shoppers would take their business elsewhere if their personal
information was at risk. One survey of 2,000 adults - commissioned by Sun Microsystems
and done by Harris Interactive - found that two-thirds of respondents expected
to shop online this holiday season. However, 67% said they were likely to stop
making online purchases if their personal information was compromised. Another
study by Forrester Custom Consumer Research, commissioned by the Business
Software Alliance, found that
Les craintes à l’endroit de la sécurité
retiendront 40% des Canadiens d’acheter leurs cadeaux de Noël en ligne cette
année, indique une récente étude de l’ACCVL, contre 24% d’Américains. Avec la
saison des fêtes qui approche à grands pas, nombreux sont les consommateurs qui
ont commencé à faire leurs emplettes de Noël. Les grandes surfaces, qui ont
déjà sorti leurs étalages de Noël, se préparent à recevoir les masses
soucieuses d’accomplir leur devoir de consommation. Certains, évidemment,
voudront éviter la cohue (on les comprend...) et se tourneront vers Internet
pour effectuer leurs achats de Noël. Mais, cette année, leur nombre ne sera apparemment
pas aussi important que ne le voudraient les marchands qui ont pignon sur le
Web. Or, des craintes au chapitre de la sécurité seraient la première
responsable de la timidité des consommateurs en ligne, selon l’Alliance
canadienne contre le vol de logiciels (ACCVL) qui vient de publier une étude
sur le sujet. [Source]
The UK Cabinet Office has published a study into
e-government practices, highlighting how governments in the most advanced
countries are moving into a new wave of electronic services and processes. This
“fourth wave” is allowing governments to change the way they do things - even
reforming legislation - rather than just creating electronic versions of existing
processes and services, the study found. This new wave is beyond e-government,
the group said, suggesting that a more accurate, if less catchy, buzzword could
be technology-enabled government, or “t-government”. The full
report, by Booz Allen Hamilton, gives a detailed analysis of common challenges
and conditions facing the US, Germany, Japan, France, UK, Italy, Canada, Sweden
and Australia, and gives case studies drawn from more than 450 initiatives that
were assessed. The idea is to give concrete examples of best practice that
governments can draw on rather than reinventing the wheel, said Jim Murphy MP,
parliamentary secretary with the Cabinet Office. “The report will challenge us
all to use ICT to make a real difference, by building on good practice examples
to deliver customer-centered public services across
E-mail spammers are aggressive as ever but Internet
providers are getting better at blocking junk messages before they reach users’
inboxes, according to a U.S. Federal Trade Commission study. The FTC found that
spammers continue to “scrape” e-mail addresses from the Web using automated
programs that look for the telltale “@” sign. [Source]
[FTC Report] [Source]
A European Union committee agreed that details of all
EU-wide phone calls and Internet use should be stored, but the committee’s
steps did not go as far as some member states had wanted in the battle against
terrorism and crime. The European Parliament’s civil liberties committee voted
33 to 8 in favor of the new rules, whereby details on telephone calls and Internet
use – but not their content – would be kept for 6–12 months. [Source]
Many health campaigners fear that the introduction of
electronic patient records will result in a loss of privacy and
confidentiality, according to research issued on 30 November 2005. A survey of
health campaigning organizations based in the
WinMagic has begun working on a pilot project with the
U.S. Department of State which would integrate a Personal Identity Verification
(PIV) card and biometrics with Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) and disk
encryption. It is designed to help the department meet HSPD-12 mandates. The
pilot project centers on the integration of a Personal Identity Verification
(PIV) card and biometrics with Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) and disk
encryption. WinMagic, along with Entrustr, Precise BiometricsT, SafeNetr, and
VMwarer are working together on the pilot project. “Proactive federal agencies
recognize the necessity to integrate data protection solutions such as the
full-disk encryption offered by WinMagic’s SecureDocr with already mandated
authentication technologies,” says Thi Nguyen-Huu, CEO, WinMagic. “These
agencies realize this will not only protect sensitive data on computers from
both internal and external security breaches, but will also prevent
unauthorized access from stolen laptops. [Source]
Call for input on the forthcoming review of the EU
regulatory framework for electronic communications and services, including
review of the Recommendation on relevant markets. Deadline 31 January 2006. The
Commission Services invite interested parties to give their views on possible
changes to the five EP and Council directives that constitute the current EU
framework for electronic communications, and to the Recommendation on relevant
markets. See consultation
document. A public workshop is provisionally planned for Tuesday 24 January
2006 in
European Commission and Council decisions that led to
a controversial agreement permitting the transfer of air passenger data to the
An FBI-style website, aimed at tracking
the
The European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS) has
sent a paper
to the heads of the EU administration, in which he addresses the Data
Protection Officer’s (DPOs) role as a strategic partner in ensuring compliance
with the data protection regulation (45/2001) without delay. One of the key messages
is that also all EU bodies need to appoint a DPO, although the appointment in
itself does not automatically mean full compliance with the regulation. A
second key message is that the DPOs must be notified more adequately of
personal data processing within their entity and that they must notify the EDPS
of any processing which entails specific risks for the people concerned and
therefore need a prior check. [Source]
With a view to achieving a higher level of EU internal
security the European Commission this week adopted a package of measures consisting
of: (a) a proposal for a Council Decision concerning the access for consultation
to the Visa Information System (VIS) to authorities of Member States
responsible for internal security and to Europol for the purposes of the
prevention, detection and investigation of terrorist offences and of other
serious criminal offences, and (b) a communication on the medium- and long-term
development of the three common European databases in the field of justice and
home affairs: the Schengen Information System (SIS), the Visa Information
System (VIS) and EURODAC, the database containing fingerprints of asylum
seekers and illegal immigrants. [Source]
More than 9,000 people in
Canadian health care facilities have built highly
secure wireless systems - but don’t expect them to use them for anything
involving electronic patient records anytime soon. That was the consensus of
the audience at a panel discussion Wednesday on overcoming challenges to
wireless security at the 4th annual summit on wireless and mobile health care
technology. “We at Saint Elizabeth Health Care partnered with
[Source]
A leading computer security analyst is predicting that
even as companies implement more IT security to prevent Internet hackers from tapping their networks, there
will be increased theft of secure data by insiders, like employees. The data
security forecast by Joseph Ansanelli, chief executive officer of the data
security firm Vontu, indicates that in 2006, as employees continue to learn
about the value of sensitive customer information -- and if they are not
trained and encouraged properly to protect this information – there is a real risk
that this information will increasingly be misused by retail employees. [Source]
The UK Select Committee on Delegated Powers and
Regulatory Reform has concluded that Parliamentary scrutiny of the ID Card Bill
needs to be enhanced. It described powers being sought in the Bill by the Home
Secretary as ‘inappropriate.’ Unlike three other Parliamentary Committees which
have criticised the substance of the Government’s ID Card proposals, this
Committee was established in the 1990s to counter ‘the considerable disquiet
over the problem of wide and sometimes ill-defined order-making powers which
give Ministers unlimited discretion’. In other words, the Committee looks at
whether the executive arm of Government is seeking excessive powers or whether
the powers being sought are subject to sufficient scrutiny by Parliament. [Source]
Forged identity cards will be “ineffective” because
they won’t be able to be verified through the central identity database, the
government has insisted. Earlier this month former MI5 chief Dame Stella Rimington
said nobody in the security services would be pushing for the cards. She warned
that if the cards could be forged they would be rendered “absolutely useless”.
But now Home Office minister Andy Burnham has highlighted that the anti-forgery
technologies used in the cards would make attempts to fake them a waste of
time. In a written response to questions from MPs he said: “The identity cards
scheme and the identity card itself are being designed to prevent the
successful production and use of forged identity cards.” He said the ID card
will be supported by an individual’s record on the National Identity Register.
[Source]
The music and film industries are demanding that the
European parliament extends the scope of proposed anti-terror laws to help them
prosecute illegal downloaders. In an open letter to MEPs, companies including
Sony BMG, Disney and EMI have asked to be given access to communications data -
records of phone calls, emails and internet surfing - in order to take legal
action against pirates and filesharers. Current proposals restrict use of such
information to cases of terrorism and organized crime. [Source]
Lawmakers plan to file a bill next year to fight the
electronic theft of credit-card information. The state does not have a law on
the books to restrict the use of the electronic scanners that can capture
information from magnetic strips. Criminals are using the scanners to steal
credit-card information. [Source]
The United Nations General Assembly has adopted a new convention
on using electronic communications in international contracting, superseding
law negotiated before the development of e-mail and the Internet. The new Convention
was approved last Wednesday. [Source]
Global cybercrime generated a higher turnover than
drug trafficking in 2004 and is set to grow even further with the wider use of
technology in developing countries, a top expert said. No country is immune
from cybercrime, which includes corporate espionage, child pornography, stock manipulation,
extortion and piracy, said an advisor to the U.S. Treasury on cybercrime. [Source]
Adrian Minnis ran a heroin distribution ring that was violent
and tightly knit, making it difficult for informers to penetrate it, federal
authorities say. The gang also had a secret weapon: It cultivated a police
officer to dig into a law enforcement
database to figure out which of its customers might be undercover informers, according
to an indictment filed against Minnis and 20 other alleged ring members. There
is no indication the officer actually identified an informer, or that his prying
into the REJIS database led to anyone being hurt. Yet the accusation against
Legislation with respect to outsourcing were
introduced in nearly all 50
The
Government Accountability Office (GAO) has released a study on offshoring that
concludes no federal data exits to inform the public about the impact of offshoring
services on a range of issues, including consumer privacy and the security of
consumers’ financial or medical data. Federal and state lawmakers are seeking
passage of bills to restrict offshoring of certain government services. [Source]
CNET’s Declan McCullagh reports on the move in the
Senate to ratify the Council of Europe’s Cybercrime Treaty. McCullagh argues
that the Convention will endanger Americans’ privacy and civil liberties and
place the FBI’s massive surveillance apparatus at the disposal of nations with
much less respect for individual liberties. [Source]
Amazon.com's wish list feature is a great way to let
relatives know what a kid wants but it's also potentially a great way for
predators to connect with kids. Creating a wish list is easy. Users register or
sign in, search for products and then click the "Add to Wish List" button.
But would-be recipients of largess must provide their shipping addresses at registration,
and, Amazon.com warns them, "We will display your city and state to help
your friends and family identify you. We won't, however, show your phone number
or street address to others." But site visitors can search wish lists by
name, presumably to see whether anyone they want to gift has set one up.
However, it's relatively easy for a stranger to find a kid simply by searching
for a common first name, then scrolling through the list to find those who have
listed last names, cities and states. Clicking through to the wish list gives a
good indication of how old the person is. [Source]
Consumers and businesses are being frustrated by a
year-long wait before complaints about privacy breaches are allocated to a case
officer, the Federal Privacy Commissioner’s office has conceded. The
commissioner’s annual report reveals the office has failed to meet its targets
and the formal investigation of privacy complaints now takes an average of 17
months. Many consumers must wait 12 months before an investigation even starts.
[Source]
The privacy commissioner has announced progress in
clearing a backlog of complaints. In the year that ended June 30, 970
complaints were cleared – 637 of which the office resolved by informal
conciliation between the parties. The office also reports that complaints have
fallen from 818 to 569. However, the commissioner expects that “the rapid
growth of information technologies” will result in an increase in privacy
complaints. [Source]
A study by Leger Marketing, Fusepoint Managed
Services, Sun Microsystems and Symantec Canada found that nearly three quarters
of respondents believe that everybody – even those who are savvy about
technology – are at equal risk of identity theft. The survey also found that an
overwhelming majority of business leaders indicate that it is important for
companies to secure data. Yet the same poll of business leaders also found that
55% say their company’s private data is at risk of an attack. [Source]
Microsoft has unveiled its new service to protect consumers
from viruses and other Internet security threats. The company eventually plans
to charge for its Windows OneCare Live, but subscription rates have not yet
been announced. The test version of OneCare updates automatically on
Internet-linked computers to protect against online threats while performing
other “PC tune-ups” to allow smooth operation. [Source]
Enterprises conducting e-commerce transactions have
been quick to take up Visa International Inc.'s free, hosted security auditing
service, according to the company. According to Visa, the free service, which
uses a
Terms like firewall, IDS, and deep packet inspection
may be indicative of today's network security landscape, but tomorrow's may
also include 'big brother' style appliances that log all user activity in an attempt
to counter internal threats. This week Israeli company Sabratec Ltd. is
launching its Intellinx monitoring solution, which has been described as
"one big sniffer", into the Australian market. It is installed on a
separate system to analyze and archive every action users perform. The
information can then be used as an audit trail in the event of fraud by
in-house employees. [Source]
The government’s Personal Identity Verification
Project calls for “secure and reliable forms of identification” for government
workers to improve security and access to all agencies. Project officials have
set standards and guidelines for the program. The federal government is
expected to issue the cards to new employees by October 2006, followed by
existing employees and contractors. The program raises questions about personal
privacy and database security. [Source]
You don’t get very far into the Driver’s Handbook
before the Ministry of Transportation sets you straight: driving is a
privilege, not a right. Soon, the ability to control your vehicle may be a
privilege, too. Transport
When you need to call someone and you don't have a
phone book, the best place to turn is 411 directory assistance. But, since cell
phone numbers are not included in directory assistance, that's not an option
for the 30% or so of mobile phone subscribers who use cell phones as their
primary or only phone, according to a study by The Pierz Group. Four national
wireless companies -- Alltel, Cingular, Sprint Nextel and T-Mobile -- have
hired Qsent Inc. to develop Wireless 411 Service, a free, optional and privacy-protected
enhancement to the providers' existing service. [Source]
A new state law requires businesses to destroy
unneeded documents containing personal information such as a Social Security
number. The law also prevents companies from using Social Security numbers for
identification purposes. [Source]
--------