Privacy News Highlights
18–24 August 2007
Contents:
US –
FBI Expanding Access to Fingerprint Database
CA – Canadian Privacy Commissioner Launches E-Learning
Tool
CA – Ponemon Institute Announces Results of 2007 Most
Trusted Companies Study
US – US to Outsource E-Authentication
WW – IBM Introduces Data Masking Solution to Safeguard
Privacy
WW – Ponemon Report: Data Lingers In Off-Network Devices
UK – Lords Report Questions Role of ISPs In Online Safety
CA – Identity Theft: 3,353 Ontarians Fell Prey to
Fraudsters Last Year
US – Lawsuit Filed on Behalf of 8.5M Consumers in Data
Breach Case Suit
WW – e-Exclusion and Bot Rights: Legal Aspects of the
Robots Exclusion Standard
US – Alaska to Permit E-Prescriptions
US – Identity Attack Spreads; 1.6M Records Stolen From
Monster.Com
US – Retirees’ Personal Info Compromised
CA – New Ontario Drivers Licences to Include Citizenship
Information as Option
US – Vermont to Participate In Hybrid ID Program
UK – UK Students Warned to Protect Personal Information
WW – Intellectual Property Holders Press for Access to
WHOIS Data
WW – Avatars Will Soon Outnumber Humans
CA – Law Enforcers Plan Canadian Cyber-Crime Centre
WW – Facebook to Introduce Advertising Based on Personal
Info
US – Auditors-General Pressure Social Media to Add
Parental Controls
WW – Google Now Zaps Faces, License Plates On Map Street
View
US – E-Voting Yields Not-So-Secret Ballots
WW – Hackers Clone RFID Passports
UK – Pupils Face Tracking Bugs in School Blazers
WW – Mobile Workers Take Too Many Security Risks: Survey
US – Giuliani: “Tamper-Proof” Biometric Card for All
Foreigners
US – California Police Camera Surveillance Increasing:
ACLU Report
US – Role of Telecom Firms in Wiretaps Confirmed
US – FCC Must Protect Innovation, Privacy in e911
Rulemaking
US – DHS Data Mining Program Suspended After Evading
Privacy Review, Audit Finds
US – DOD Pulls Plug on TALON Database
WW – Airport Security Screening is Worst of All Possible
Worlds: Economist
CA – Canadian Court Protects Worker’s Casual Drug Use
US – Survey Says: Half of Employers Restrict Facebook
US – NYC Taxi Drivers Set Strike Date to Protest GPS
Systems
The FBI is ready to move out of the test stage in
sharing fingerprint data with other agencies. Tom Bush, assistant director at
the bureau’s Criminal Justice Information Service (CJIS) office, this week the
FBI is going forward on all fronts to extend access to its Integrated Automated
Fingerprint Identification System (IAFIS) database to the Defence, Homeland
Security and State departments. Bush said civilian agencies account for about
54% of the checks against IAFIS. He also said with the interoperability
success, CJIS hopes to expand the intelligence community’s use of the
databases. Bush said IAFIS was built to do about 62,000 fingerprint checks a
day, but it is handling more than 115,000 a day. He said that is the main
reason the FBI is upgrading IAFIS to the Next Generation Identification system.
Industry submitted proposals earlier this month, and Bush said an award is
expected by December. [Source]
See also: [New
Fingerprinting System Gets Thumbs Down: Thousand of Teachers' Fingerprints
Rejected by FBI]
Retailers now have a free, do-it-yourself interactive
tool to help them bring their privacy practices and policies in line with the
law, the Privacy Commissioner of Canada announced this week. The new e-learning
tool created by the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada (OPC) provides
retailers with the information to set up their business to meet their
obligations under Canada’s privacy laws and provide customers with the privacy
protection they’re guaranteed under PIPEDA.
The online retailer training session takes about 30 minutes to complete.
At the end, retailers will have: an information audit of their business;
consent provisions required specifically for their business; a security plan; a
sample privacy brochure for customers; and a training needs assessment. [Source]
[Interactive
Tool]
Carlson Marketing Worldwide and the Ponemon Institute
have announced the results of the 2007 Canada’s Most Trusted Companies for
Privacy Study, an annual report that ranks public perception of companies’
privacy and data security practices. The study included both Canadian companies
and global brands operating in Canada and found that the top three most trusted
brands are Bell Canada, Bank of Montreal and Royal Bank of Canada. Financial
services and telecommunications companies had a solid showing, capturing six of
the top ten positions. Canadian brands earned seven of the top ten spots,
including the top four rankings. [Source]
E-government has matured to the point that federal
agencies are now willing to pay a fee for e-authentication services to verify
people’s identities online. That’s the conclusion reached by the federal
E-Authentication Executive Steering Committee, which approved a new
fee-for-service policy in June. A transition to the new business model will
occur in spring 2008, officials said. The federal program office that manages
e-authentication services is now part of the General Services Administration’s
Federal Acquisition Service. Georgia Marsh, former acting program executive for
e-authentication, described the policy change as a major milestone and turning
point in the federal government’s e-authentication history. E-authentication is
one of 25 e-government initiatives that the Bush administration introduced in
2002 as part of the President’s Management Agenda. [Source]
IBM this week announced a new Data Masking Solution
that helps protect critical data without disrupting customer service or product
development. With these sophisticated Data Masking techniques, the solution is
designed to transform data so that no sensitive information is exposed while
allowing internal and external developers to perform software product design,
development, testing and quality assurance. Data Masking is the process of
identifying sensitive data and overlaying values that “masks” the sensitive
data, but does not compromise the functional integrity of an application.
Today, data masking is accomplished manually by companies’ technical subject
matter experts. The task needs to be repeated as large companies have hundreds
of business applications that are all tightly integrated. IBM’s Data Masking
Solution can execute this masking process in a timely and cost-effective way
across the enterprise. [Source]
[IBM’s
Data Masking Solution]
Data breaches such as the one reported by Merrill
Lynch earlier this month – through which the company lost some 33,000 employee
records via a laptop stolen from a New Jersey office – could be avoided if
companies did a better job of managing and defending information stored on
devices that move off of corporate networks, according to a new report
published by Ponemon Institute. Presented by its authors at the Privacy Symposium being held
at Harvard University, the study – which is based on a survey completed by 735
senior IT security professionals -- finds that 73% of those corporations it
interviewed experienced the loss or theft of a data-bearing machine sometime in
the last 2 years. Despite that reality, and the fact that 62% of study
respondents admitted that they were unsure if their off-network equipment
contains unprotected sensitive or confidential information, some 39% said they
do not view the management of such devices as a “critical component” to
security. In a nod to the lack of tools being used by businesses to track data
leakage, 30% of those individuals responding to the survey said they would
never be able to detect the loss or theft of confidential data from off-network
equipment when it happened. Unsurprisingly, based on the results, Ponemon found
that a vast majority 70% of all data breaches result from the loss of
off-network equipment, including laptops, PDAs and cell phones. [Source]
[Source]
A new report on internet safety has concluded ISPs
(internet service providers) should take more responsibility for online
security since end users are often lax. But the 121-page Personal Internet
Security report, published this month by the UK House of Lords, stopped short
of suggesting that the Office of Communications (Ofcom) - the UK communications
regulator - should impose new rules on ISPs. [Source]
According to statistics compiled by the Canadian
Anti-Fraud Call Centre, more commonly known as Phone Busters, identity theft
was responsible for more than $16.2 million in losses in Canada last year. More
than $7.5 million of that occurred in Ontario, with 3,353 reported victims. [Source]
See also: [Your
data’s less safe today than two years ago: Crooks are outpacing prevention
efforts; ID theft is up 50% since 2003] See also: [Anatomy
of a data breach from the inside out]
Check verification company Certegy and its parent
company, Fidelity National Information Services Inc., face a class action
lawsuit in connection with the theft of 8.5 million consumer records. The
company announced last month that a former senior database administrator
accessed and then sold consumers’ financial and personal information to
marketing firms. The lawsuit alleges negligence, invasion of privacy and breach
of implied contract. [Source]
[Source]
See also: [US Federal
Court Slaps Data Theft Victims and Ruling]
Public sector use of the robot exclusion standard
raises interesting questions about transparency, availability of public sector
information and the principle of public access to information. This paper
explores both actual examples of how public sector agencies in Sweden use the
standard and an analysis of the legal problems related to use of the standard.
[Source]
Electronic drug prescriptions can be delivered to
pharmacists in all 50 states for the first time this week as Alaska became the
final state to join the technological bandwagon. In the past year, Georgia,
South Carolina and West Virginia have all joined the national network, and the
change in Alaska regulations means doctors’ hieroglyphic handwriting and
prescription pads could soon be a thing of the past. [Source]
The 46,000 people reportedly infected by ads on job
sites may be only a fraction of the victims of an ambitious, multistage attack
that has stolen data belonging to several hundred thousand people who posted
resumes on Monster.com, a researcher said last weekend. According to Symantec
Corp., a new Trojan horse has stolen more than 1.6 million records belonging to
several hundred thousand people from Monster Worldwide Inc.’s job search
service. That data is then used to target the Monster.com users with credible
phishing mail that plants more malware on their machines. The personal
information filched from Monster.com includes names, e-mail addresses, home
address, phone numbers and resume identification numbers. “Such a large
database of highly personal information is a spammer’s dream,” said a Symantec
Researcher. [Source]
[Source]
[Monster Waited Five
Days to Disclose Data Theft] See also: [Resumes: A Favorite
Phishing Hole for Spammers]
Personal information about hundreds of thousands of retirees’
may have been compromised after two security breaches involving pension funds
in California and New York. In the New York case, a laptop computer containing
financial information on as many as 280,000 retired New York City workers
disappeared from a restaurant. In California, a pension fund brochure that was
mailed to 445,000 retired state workers last week revealed all or part of each person’s
Social Security number on the envelope. [Source]
[California
State Pension Fund Admits Breach of Retiree Data]
Ontarians will have the option to add citizenship
information to their driver’s licences when the province introduces its new
cards, Transportation Minister Donna Cansfield said this week. The province is
slated to unveil new licences at the end of 2007 that it hopes will be able to
double as pass cards at the New York and Michigan borders. British Columbia
received approval for a similar enhanced driver’s licence pilot project in
March. The active working group will be meeting again in the next couple of
weeks to discuss any further requirements. [Source]
The state of Vermont has forged an agreement with the
Homeland Security Department to launch a hybrid identification card that
combines a driver’s license with a border-crossing card. Following the lead of
Washington State, Vermont intends to become the second border state to produce
an enhanced driver’s license that potentially will serve as an acceptable
document for crossing U.S. borders under the Western Hemisphere Travel
Initiative. [Source]
The UK Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) is
urging new and returning university students to protect their personal
information as the new academic year approaches. It said students are more
likely to be invited to sign up for new services and societies within the first
few days and weeks of the academic year. The warning comes as a recent survey
conducted by the ICO revealed that young people appear to protect their
personal information less well than any other age group. The survey of 1,223 UK
adults aged over 16 and conducted by market research firm Tickbox found that
more than half (5%) use the same passwords for more than one account. And one
in five failed to properly destroy bank statements or receipts before throwing
them in the bin. The ICO is directing
concerned students to a free online guide designed to help them protect and
manage their personal information. The ICO Personal Information Toolkit
includes advice and tips on how to access the personal information
organisations hold, how to correct inaccurate information and how to reduce
unwanted marketing calls and texts. [Source]
The seven-year-old battle over access to WHOIS data --
the names, street addresses, e-mail addresses and phone numbers of those who
have registered Internet domains -- remains a stalemate this week, leaving
reforms undone. The conflict pits individuals and groups that favor privacy
protections against organizations and law enforcement agencies that favor data
access to police intellectual property and to curtail cybercrime. In a blog
post on the Internet Governance Project’s (IGP) Web site, Milton Mueller,
Professor and Director of the Telecommunications Network Management Program at
the Syracuse University School of Information Studies and a partner in the IGP,
details the Final
Outcomes Report of the WHOIS Working Group, published on Tuesday, and
inability of the various stakeholders to reach any kind of consensus. [Source]
[Background]
Gartner research indicates that in four years’ time
80% of internet users will have avatars - virtual replicas of themselves -
working or playing online. Given the pace of internet adoption, and the fact
that people often have more than one avatar, there will soon be more avatars
than humans, at least in the industrialised world. How, if at all, this will
change society is fascinating to predict. [Source]
The Canadian Association of Police Boards’ initiative
to establish a global centre for cyber crime in Canada got a boost this week
with a $100,000 pledge from Public Safety Minister Stockwell Day. The CyberPol
Global Centre for Securing Cyberspace is envisioned to become a centralized
collaboration centre for Canadian and international law enforcement agencies in
a bid to combat all forms of cyber crime, according to Ian Wilms, president of
the Canadian Association of Police Boards (CAPB). The federal government’s
contribution will help fund a national study the CAPB will conduct on the
impact of cyber crime on all sectors of Canadian society. The study will
involve both businesses and consumers to get a sense of the extent of
computer-related crimes in Canada, including child exploitation, financial
fraud, identity theft and intellectual property offences. The cyber crime impact
study will be conducted over the next four months, after which the CAPB will
release a national report “so Canadians can become aware,” Wilms said. At the
same time, the CAPB will commence work on a feasibility study that will bring
together various law enforcement agencies, including the RCMP and municipal
police forces, technology experts, as well as security partners from the U.S.
and other countries to determine what the best model for the CyberPol Centre
would be, he said. [Source]
Social-networking Web site Facebook Inc. is quietly
working on a new advertising system that would let marketers target users with
ads based on the massive amounts of information people reveal on the site about
themselves. Eventually, it hopes to refine the system to allow it to predict
what products and services users might be interested in even before they have
specifically mentioned an area. [Source] See
also: [YouTube
To Start Selling Ads In Videos]
The attorneys general of all 50 states have joined
forces to pressure MySpace, Facebook Inc. and other Internet social-networking
sites to put in place greater parental controls and age-verification tools so
minors can’t access the sites so easily. Led by Richard Blumenthal and Roy
Cooper, the attorneys general of Connecticut and North Carolina, respectively,
the group is working together to pressure the social-networking sites for
changes and push for new laws. [Source]
Now anyone can alert the company and have an image of license
plate or a recognizable face removed, not just the owner of the face or car. Google
has gotten a lot of flack from privacy advocates for photographing faces and
license plate numbers and displaying them on the Street View in Google Maps.
Originally, the company said only people who identified themselves could ask
the company to remove their image. But Google has quietly changed that policy,
partly in response to criticism, and now anyone can alert the company and have
an image of a license plate or a recognizable face removed, not just the owner
of the face or car, says Marissa Mayer, vice president of search products and
user experience at Google. [Source]
Ohio’s method of conducting elections with electronic
voting machines appears to have created a true privacy nightmare for state
residents, as the method reveals who voted for which candidates. Two Ohio
activists have discovered that e-voting machines made by Election Systems and
Software and used across the country produce time-stamped paper trails that
permit the reconstruction of an election’s results, including allowing voter
names to be matched to their actual votes. [Source]
High-tech passports touted as “advances in national
security” can be spied on with remote-control technology and their radio
signals cloned. A conference of computer hackers were shown the techniques last Sunday. Radio frequency
identification technology (RFID) - used in cash cards and passports and also in
security passes by members of Indian Parliament - could be copied, blocked or imitated, said
Melanie Rieback, a privacy researcher at Vrije University in Netherlands.
Rieback demonstrated a device she and her colleagues at Vrije built to hijack
the RFID signals that manufacturers have touted as “unreadable by anything
other than proprietary scanners”. “I spend most of my time making RFID
industry’s life miserable,” a doctoral researcher said. “I am not anti-RFID. It
has the potential to make people’s lives easier, but it needs to be used
responsibly.” Rieback and her university compatriots are expected to have a
portable version of their device - RFID Guardian - ready in six months but
“have no plans to immediately mass-produce them.” “Hackers” present in the conference room
cheered when Rieback announced that the schematics and the computer codes for
the device would be made public. [Source]
A UK school uniform maker said yesterday it was
“seriously considering” adding tracking devices to its clothes after a survey
found many parents would be interested in knowing where their offspring were. Trutex
would not say whether it was studying a spy in the waistband or a bug in the
blazer but admitted teenagers were less keen than younger children on the “big
brother” idea. The Lancashire company, which sells 1m blouses, 1.1m shirts,
250,000 pairs of trousers, 200,000 blazers, 60,000 skirts and 110,000 pieces of
knitwear each year, commissioned an online survey for 809 parents and 444
children aged between nine and 16. It said 44% of the adults were worried about
the safety of pre-teen children and 59% would be interested in satellite
tracking systems being incorporated in schoolwear. While nearly four in 10
pupils aged 12 and under were prepared to go along with the idea, teenagers
were more wary of “spying”. [Source]
See also: [Domestic
Satellite-Surveillance Plan Draws Scrutiny]
A global study into mobile workers’ attitudes to IT
security suggests there is still much work to be done in raising awareness of
security threats and best practices while working on the move. The survey, carried
out by market researcher InsightExpress, found almost three quarters (73%) of
mobile users claimed that they were not always mindful of security issues.
Although many said they are aware “sometimes” of the risks and threats, 28%
admitted that they “hardly ever” consider security risks and proper behaviour.
More worryingly, some of the 700 mobile users surveyed for the study
commissioned by Cisco and the National Cyber Security Alliance (NCSA) even
admitted that they “never” consider safe best practices and didn’t know they
needed to be aware of security risks. [Source]
Every foreigner in America, including British
visitors, would be required to carry an ID card bearing photograph and
fingerprints under plans drawn up by Rudolph Giuliani, the frontrunner for the
Republican presidential nomination.
Giuliani is hoping to cement his status as the Republican favourite by
promising to enforce immigration and border controls, drawing on expertise in
combating crime from his time as mayor of New York. He announced last week that
all foreigners, including holiday-makers, would be obliged to carry a
“tamper-proof” biometric card, which could be issued at ports of entry. “If you don’t have that card, you get thrown
out of the country,” Giuliani said. He intends to call it a Safe card (for
secure authorized foreign entry). [Source]
Backed by millions in Homeland Security dollars,
California law enforcement authorities are quickly expanding video surveillance
camera spying in public rights of way, a move the American Civil Liberties
Union says is stripping away privacy rights while failing to dent the intended
purpose: crime. The ACLU report says at least 37 agencies and cities, big and
small, have some form of a video surveillance program or are planning one
directed at combating crime. And as more cities look to install their own
monitoring devices, there’s little empirical evidence that the cameras are
deterring crime or helping solve cases. Instead, the surveillance “gives the
government a vast quantity of information on private citizens that would
otherwise be unavailable, allowing it to monitor people engaging in wholly
innocent and constitutionally protected behavior,” according to the report,
released Monday. [Source]
[ACLU
Report]
The Bush administration has confirmed for the first
time that American telecommunications companies played a crucial role in the
National Security Agency’s domestic eavesdropping program after asserting for
more than a year that any role played by them was a “state secret.” The acknowledgment
was in an unusual interview that Mike McConnell, the director of national
intelligence, gave last week to The El Paso Times in which he disclosed details
on classified intelligence issues that the administration has long insisted
would harm national security if discussed publicly. [Source] [Secret Court Asks for White House View on
Inquiry] [Spy
chief reveals details of operations]
CDT, the Electronic Frontier Foundation and Sun
Microsystems this week urged the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) to be
cautious in considering an “automatic” location requirement for VoIP providers
for use during e911 emergency calls. In comments filed today with the FCC, the
groups noted that while the e911 system is a vital part of our public safety
net, VoIP services are unable to provide “automatic” location information (without
user input), and a requirement that they do so would harm innovation and
competition. The comments also cautioned
that some proposed solutions to address the VoIP location requirement would
destroy users’ privacy. August 22, 2007 [CDT e911 Comments]
A controversial Homeland Security data mining system
called ADVISE that dreamed of searching through trillions of records culled
from government, public and private databases analyzed personal information
without the required privacy oversight, may cost more than commercially
available alternatives and has been suspended until a privacy review has been
completed, according to an internal audit. The Analysis, Dissemination,
Visualization, Insight, and Semantic Enhancement program, one of twelve DHS
data mining efforts, hit the trifecta of civil libertarians concerns about data
mining programs - invasiveness, secrecy and ineffectiveness, according to a
recent DHS Inspector General report. [Source]
[DHS
Inspector General report]
The Defense Department announced today that it would
close an intelligence reporting database that had come under legal fire as a
means of storing information about peaceful domestic critics of Bush
administration policies. The Threat and Local Observation Notice (Talon)
database had become a lightning rod for criticism of military intelligence
agencies’ monitoring of antiwar protestors. The decision to shut it down
resonated with parallel litigation and debate about the legality of federal
monitoring of international telecommunications. Technological changes in
international telecommunications that have arisen since the disclosure of
Vietnam War-era domestic spying prompted new civil-liberties protections figure
in current privacy debates. The Pentagon said it would close Talon as of Sept.
17 and “maintain a record copy of the collected data in accordance with
intelligence oversight requirements,” said a department press statement issued
today. The ACLU, which had sued DOD to gain access to Talon records under the Freedom of Information Act, praised the
decision to shut down the system. [Source] See also: [Secret Spy
Court To Consider ACLU Request For Bush Spying Orders] [Is Bush
Administration Redefining New Spy Law?]
The security system now in place at most of America’s
big international airports is the worst of all possible worlds-neither
respectful of people’s privacy and rights, nor particularly effective in terms
of security, according to an article in The Economist. Privacy problems remain,
however. Passengers still won’t be able to find out why they have been targeted
for extensive searches or kept off flights. And they still won’t be able to
correct mistakes on watch lists. Before Secure Flight is resurrected, lawmakers
need to insist that greater transparency is built into the system, and that
one-in-ten false positives is wholly unacceptable. [Source]
Two competing cases on the controversial practice of
workplace drug testing show a growing schism in the courts on the validity of
such actions, making it harder for employers to figure out when their practices
are outside the bounds of the law. Both cases deal with employees who were
terminated after testing positive for marijuana use during pre-employment
screening. Neither employee claimed to be drug dependent, which can be
considered a disability under some provincial human-rights legislation. The
cases also considered Entrop v. Imperial Oil, the leading Canadian drug-testing
ruling, which came down hard on employers who test employees and prospective
employees, even in safety-sensitive positions. [Source]
Half of businesses are restricting employees’ access
to social-networking site Facebook, due to concerns about productivity and
security. According to research by security company Sophos, 43 percent of
workers polled said their employer blocks Facebook access completely. Security
experts warn that details such as employment history and mobile phone numbers
have been found on the site and could be used for identity theft or to launch
corporate phishing attacks. [Source]
A group of 10,000 New York taxi drivers has vowed to
strike for two days, Sept. 5 and 6, primarily to protest GPS systems being
installed in their cabs. The New York Taxi Workers Alliance, which has 10,000
cab drivers as members, has been threatening a strike for several weeks, and
set the strike dates today in a New York press conference. Executive Director
Bhairavi Desai called the strike “a fight for dignity” because of concerns the
GPS systems could be used to locate drivers and invade their privacy,
especially when they are off-duty. [Source]
--------