Privacy News Highlights
13—19 May 2006
Contents:
AU – Biometrics
for All Australian Visas
ON – Ontario Website Seeks Public Help to
Identify Dead, Find Missing
CA – U.S. Must Use Caution with Passport
Plan: Wilson
CA – Alberta & War Amps Reach
Compromise Over Drivers’ Licence Data.
WW – Report: Government Agencies Rival Private Sector in
Delivering Customer Service
US – Kodak Service Agrees to Pay Fine for Violating Spam
Law
WW – Report: Record Management Is Complicated, Costly
US – Major Issues When Designing Privacy Into Corporate
Databases
UK – UK Legislation to Enforce Encryption Key Disclosure
WW – Credit Card Security Rules to Get Update
EU – EU Data
Retention Directive In Force
WW – Poll Measures Level of Concern About Privacy,
Technology In Five Countries
CA – Senator Pushes Looser Privacy Laws
Vis-À-Vis FINTRAC
CA – Reid Urges Changes to Proposed
Accountability Act
CA – Alberta Government Forcing Through
Changes on Info Law
CA – National DNA Data Bank Surpasses
Milestone
US – Medical ID Theft Leaves Thousands Ailing
CA – Canadian Consumer Takes Steps to
Protect Her Privacy
US – Border ID Deadline Extended
US – Bush Signs Order to Create Identity Theft Task Force
CA – Queens University Workshop on National
Identification Cards
UK – Group Seeks Anti-ID Card Support
CA – Privacy Experts Detail Concerns About
Proposed Changes to Copyright Law
AU – Australia Proposes New Copyright Exceptions
AU – Australian Police Peeked At Database Files
WW – The Security Implications of Outsourcing
WW – Search Engine Advertisers Blamed for Spyware, Spam
US – Philadelphia City Council Approves Wireless Internet
Network
US – DHS Privacy Office Slams RFID Technology
EU – Transparency ‘Crucial’ for RFID Systems
US – VeriSign RFID Implants for Immigrants – CASPIAN’s
“Jaw Dropping” Proposal
US – FTC Takes Action Against Real Estate Services Firm
For Lax Security Practices
US – IRS Procedural Flaws Leave Taxpayer Materials
Vulnerable
WW – Microsoft Vista OS Contains Broad Security Feature
AU – Australian Privacy Commissioner Issues Checklist of
Concerns for Smart Cards
US – Judge Rules EFF Can Keep Sealed Docs in Domestic
Spying Suit
US – Lawmakers Received Briefings on Surveillance
US – FCC Commissioner: Privacy Still Matters Even as
Government Fights Terrorism
US – Former FCC Chairman Comments on Efforts to Balance
National Security, Privacy
US – CIA Nominee Defends Domestic Surveillance Programs
US – Telecoms Face Lawsuits for Turning Over Customer
Call Records To Feds
US – Wireless Industry Call for Voluntary Privacy
Standards
US – GAO Official Cites Privacy Risk in RFID and
Data-Mining
US – Privacy: Key Challenges Facing Federal Agencies
US – Subpanel Approves Bill Requiring Privacy Review For
Federal Rules
US – ISP Snooping Plans Take Backseat
US – Lawmakers Try to Restrict Usage of Social Security
Numbers
US – New York Lawmakers Approve Package of ID Theft Bills
US – Three More American States Enact Data Breach
Notification Laws
IN – Indian Employee Biometric Database to be Mandatory
for Outsourcing Jobs
US – Workplace Monitoring Requires Careful Analysis of
Privacy Rights
All international visitors seeking to come to
Provincial police in
The
In an agreement reached by the province and the War
Amps recently, Albertans renewing their driver’s licence after June 5 will be
asked to fill out a form saying whether or not they want their contact information
given to the group’s key tag program. [Source]
According to a new research report by Accenture,
entitled “Leadership in Customer Service: Building the Trust”, government
agencies that lead the public sector in customer service are focused on
developing sophisticated, interactive and transactional capabilities on par
with the best of the private sector. In the report, Accenture finds a new trend
whereby government agencies are reinventing their customer service delivery
programs in order to help build greater trust - and this is redefining the
relationship between citizens and their governments. From allowing drivers to
pay for street parking using their mobile phones to using text messaging for
“amber alerts” on missing children to installing interactive kiosks that
provide information about city events, dining, shopping, and entertainment,
government agencies around the world are adopting innovative new approaches to
deliver value to citizens. [Source]
[News
Release]
A digital photo-sharing service run by Eastman Kodak
Co. settled charges it sent e-mails to 2 million recipients and failed to give
them a way to opt out of future messages, the Federal Trade Commission said.
Kodak Imaging Network, previously known as Ofoto Inc., agreed to pay a $26,331
penalty for violating a
The Information Security Forum (ISF) has issued a
report that highlights the difficulties businesses face when it comes to record
management. Email, Instant Messaging, mobile SMS and IP voice technology are
complicating business decisions around data retention. Businesses face laws and
regulations that require them to manage and keep business records, but data
privacy laws may prevent the retention of records – leaving many organizations
in a quandary, said an ISF research consultant. The ISF relied on the
experiences of its members to suggest best practices, including creating a
record retention policy and using a risk approach to decide which documents
should be considered business records. [Source]
Much of the attention in the privacy profession has
focused on legal and administrative affairs. For most companies and government
agencies, privacy ultimately involves a number of technical choices about how
information is captured, stored and managed in their databases. An article in DMReview takes a look at some of the key
architectural decisions that must be made to help databases put privacy into action.
[Source]
The British government is preparing to give its police
the authority to force organizations and individuals to disclose encryption
keys, a move that has outraged some security and civil-rights experts. The
legislation that gives the police such authority is contained within Part 3 of
the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act. The RIP Act, also known as RIPA, was introduced in 2000, but the
government has held back from bringing Part 3 into effect. [Source]
Changes
to the Payment Card Industry (PCI) Data Security Standard are expected this
summer. One change involves an effort to accommodate complaints from merchants
who have encountered difficulties with encryption requirements. Another change
will require merchants to assess weaknesses in payment software by mid-2008.
Security experts laud the vulnerability assessment. However, the relaxation on
the encryption standard by allowing businesses to adopt alternatives may
potentially pose increased data security risks to consumers, experts warn. [Source] [Source]
This month, a highly controversial European law came
into effect that raises concerns about our fundamental right to privacy. Even
before the final text was officially published, the directive had been criticised
by several of
Roy Morgan International conducted a poll that found
the
A senator is ringing alarm bells about
The government’s Accountability
Act will actually hamper people’s ability to ferret out government secrets
and should be changed, Information Commissioner John Reid said Thursday. Mr.
Reid told a Commons committee that the bill needs amendments to eliminate a
number of exemptions that will allow some government agencies to keep
information hidden forever. [Source]
In recognition of Police Week, the Honourable
Stockwell Day was joined by RCMP Commissioner Giuliano Zaccardelli in
congratulating the National DNA Data Bank (NDDB) on its recent milestone of
5,000 hits. Since it began operating in June 2000, the NDDB has consistently
proven to be a powerful investigative tool in helping law enforcement solve
crime, including the most serious offences. [Source]
The World Privacy Forum recently issued a report on
medical ID theft. The report estimated that 250,000 to 500,000 consumers have
been affected after people used their identities or insurance coverage for
treatment or submitted fake bills to claim the reimbursements for services
never rendered by any physician. Oftentimes, victims find out long after the
fraud occurred when bill collectors seek payment for costly procedures. Another
danger faced by these consumers is having their medical records tainted by
false information about their health, which could lead to treatment errors. [Source]
A
Canadian cell phone customer was stunned to find that an online check of her
account revealed that another customer’s information was visible and linked to
her bill. A company spokesman said the Web site was shut down immediately and
steps were taken to fix the foul-up. [Source]
The U.S. Senate voted this week to delay for 17 months
a requirement Americans re-entering the
U.S. President George W. Bush signed an executive
order on Wednesday to create a task force to crack down on identity theft. “Identity
theft is a serious problem in
Drs. Colin Bennett and David Lyons will be leading an
international research workshop at Queen’s under the GPD banner – on national
identification cards June 7-9 2007. [Source]
Campaigners against a
Canadian privacy experts and other groups have issued
an open letter to the ministers of Canadian heritage and industry that highlights
their concerns about how proposed changes to Canadian copyright law would
affect privacy, freedom of expression and civil liberties. The group is
concerned in particular about the extension of legal protections to Digital
Rights Management (DRM) technology. In separate letters, Canadian Privacy
Commissioner Jennifer Stoddart,
Dozens of police officers in
Concerns about data security and the qualifications of
Sites that pay to have their links pop up on search
engine result pages are nearly three times more likely to harbor spyware or
adware, or hassle users with spam than URLs generated by the engine’s
algorithms, research claimed. And search engines are cashing in, reported
McAfee’s SiteAdvisor service. By its estimate, the search industry made $1.1
billion from risky sponsored links last year. [Source]
The Philadelphia City Council unanimously approved a
plan to blanket the city’s 135 square miles with a high-speed wireless Internet
connection, a measure the mayor is expected to sign soon. If the system is
fully deployed by the third quarter of 2007 as planned,
The Homeland Security Department’s Privacy Office has
issued a draft report from a technology analysis group that strongly criticizes
the personal privacy and security risks of using radio frequency identification
device units for human identification and says the technology offers little
performance benefit over competing methods. The Privacy Office is seeking
comments on the report, which are due by May 22. The department’s Emerging
Applications and Technology Subcommittee of the Data Privacy and Integrity
Advisory Committee prepared the report, which is titled “The Use of RFID for
Human Identification.” [Source] [Source]
[DHS
Report]
Several consumer organizations this week called on the
European Commission to ensure that there is increased transparency in RFID
systems, to ensure that consumers’ privacy is protected. The comments were made
during a workshop held by the European Commission that discussed privacy issues
around RFID. The workshop, part of the EC’s current consultation into the use
of RFID tags in
Katherine Albrecht and CASPIAN have issued a press
release claiming that the head of VeriChip Corporation wants to put RFID
tracking chips in immigrants. [Source]
[Source] [Source]
Nations Title Agency and its parent company, Nations
Holding Co., have reached a settlement with the FTC over allegations that the
company had overstated the extent of its data security practices. According to
the FTC, the company discarded consumer home loan applications in an unsecured
Dumpster. Under the settlement, the Kansas City-based company agreed not to
misrepresent its data protection policies. It also agreed to adopt and maintain
a data security program, subject to outside audits for 20 years. [Source]
Taxpayer receipts and other sensitive materials were
left open and vulnerable to loss or theft, and it was common to find problems
with financial and security procedures at Internal Revenue Service facilities
visited by auditors during an annual review. As part of a fiscal 2005 audit,
Government Accountability Office employees visited a sampling of service
centers, taxpayer assistance centers, field offices, financial institutions
serving as agents of the government and a finance center, to evaluate how they
followed financial and internal controls designed to ensure the appropriate
handling of materials. [Source]
An annoying surprise awaits 2 million consumers
expected to enthusiastically step forward in the next few weeks to help
Microsoft test its new Windows Vista PC operating system. Volunteers who test
Vista Beta 2, a near-final version of the much-hyped upgrade of Windows, can
expect to encounter an obtrusive security feature, called User Account Control.
[Source]
See also [Government
Okays’ Vista Search] and [U.S. Wants to Add Two Years
to Microsoft Settlement] [Symantec Sues
to prevent release of Vista] [MS
on the Future]
Commissioner Paul Chadwick is raising awareness about
the privacy implications of the government’s proposed smart card, which
Australians will need to access welfare and Medicare services. Chadwick said
questions remain about what databases will be linked to the information
contained on the cards. Safeguards must be in place to prevent unauthorized
access. [Source]
A
US National Intelligence Director John Negroponte
declassified a list of 30 congressional briefings the Bush administration says
have been held since the National Security Agency began its no-warrant surveillance
program after the Sept. 11 attacks. Half of the briefings took place between
Oct. 25, 2001 and the public disclosure of the program this past December. The
remaining 15 occurred over the past five months and included an expanded group
of lawmakers who were told of the program’s operational details. [Source]
In the wake of revelations that telecommunications
companies may be providing consumers’ telephone records to the National
Security Agency, a Federal Communications Commission (FCC) commissioner,
Michael J. Copps, is calling for an investigation into whether the companies
are violating federal communications law. Copps, a Democrat, said in a
statement that the federal government’s top priority is protecting the security
of Americans. But he added that “the privacy of our citizens must still matter.”
[Source]
Michael Powell, the former chairman of the FCC, said
this week that Americans understand the sacrifices required for security after
9-11. In the
CIA director nominee Gen. Michael Hayden defended the
secret surveillance programs he oversaw while head of another spy agency as
lawful and designed to “preserve the security and the liberty of the American
people.” Hayden’s visits to lawmakers on Capitol Hill were complicated by
reaction to public disclosure of the National Security Agency program that has
been building a database of millions of Americans’ everyday telephone calls. [Source]
[Background]
[coverage]
[coverage]
[coverage]
[coverage]
Telecom companies say they have safeguarded their
customers’ privacy, but those assurances have not stopped attorneys for
subscribers from suing for billions of dollars in civil damages. A federal
lawsuit was filed recently against one telecommunications company for $50
billion in civil damages. [Source]
[Source]
[Coverage] [Coverage]
[Source]
[Source]
[Coverage]
The general counsel of the Cellular Telecommunications
and Internet Association, an international trade association that represents
wireless carriers, pointed out during a recent panel discussion that many companies
that use geographic location technology in their products are not subject to
the same federal standards as wireless phone carriers. In 2000, the trade group
asked the FCC to adopt new privacy
requirements after the decision to install geographic-tracking technology
in cell phones. The FCC in 2002 turned down the group’s request, which led the
industry to adopt its own privacy standards. [Source]
Federal
agencies are falling short in protecting privacy when performing data mining,
according to congressional testimony from a senior Government Accountability
Office official. Both data mining-in which large amounts of data from different
sources are aggregated, searched and analyzed-and radio-frequency
identification technologies are raising privacy concerns, Linda Koontz,
director of information management issues for GAO, said in testimony before the
House Judiciary Subcommittee on Commercial and Administrative Law this week. Koontz
added that although agencies that use data mining took many necessary steps,
including issuing public notices, to protect privacy, none of them followed
such key procedures as including in the notices the intended use of the
information. [Source]
Advances in information technology make it easier than
ever for the federal government to obtain and process personal information
about citizens and residents in many ways and for many purposes. To ensure that
the privacy rights of individuals are respected, this information must be
properly protected in accordance with current law, particularly the Privacy Act and the E-Government Act of 2002. These laws prescribe specific activities
that agencies must perform to protect privacy, and the Office of Management and
Budget (OMB) has developed guidance on how and in what circumstances agencies
are to carry out these activities. Many agencies designate officials as focal
points for privacy-related matters, and increasingly, many have created senior
positions, such as chief privacy officer, to assume primary responsibility for
privacy policy, as well as dedicated privacy offices. GAO was asked to testify
on key challenges facing agency privacy officers. To address this issue, GAO
identified and summarized issues raised in its previous reports on privacy. [Source]
Federal agencies would be required to assess the
privacy implications of any new or proposed rule under legislation approved
Wednesday by a House subcommittee, but the measure appears to have little
chance of becoming law despite the recent and ongoing furor over reports that
certain phone companies have been giving calling data to the federal
government. The Federal Agency Protection of Privacy Act (H.R. 2840)
was approved by voice vote by the House Judiciary Commercial and Administrative
Law Subcommittee. There were no amendments, although ranking member Melvin
Watt, D-N.C., said he might offer an amendment later. [Source]
Rep. F. James Sensenbrenner, the chairman of the House
Judiciary Committee, has backed away from plans to rewrite Internet privacy
rules by requiring that logs of Americans’ online activities be stored. CNET
reported this week that Sensenbrenner wanted to require ISPs to track what
their users were doing so police might more easily “conduct criminal investigations,”
including inquiries into cases involving child exploitation and pornography. [Source] [Background]
The possibility that
The state Assembly has approved several bills intended
to help consumers whose information is used to make fraudulent purchases.
Lawmakers approved a security freeze bill that would allow consumers to send a
certified letter to a credit agency via certified mail to request that their
credit be inaccessible. Credit bureaus would have five days to respond to the
consumer’s request. Consumers would be provided with a secret password to give
to a credit reporting agency when account information was requested during a
security freeze. Lawmakers also passed a phishing bill and another measure that
would require businesses to properly dispose of or destroy records that contain
personal information. [Source]
The National Skills Registry has been established by
the National Association of Software and Service Companies (Nasscom),
As employers consider ID management systems, the
intersection of security and personal privacy can be a minefield for companies.
Several laws come into play - the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act, Data
Protection Act, Computer Misuse law, the Employment Code of Practice and the
Human Rights Act. Privacy rights can be trumped if the employer informs the
employee that they will be monitored. Experts warn that before a company
introduces a new ID management system, they should check with attorneys to make
sure they have adequate protections to protect employee privacy and safeguards
to secure private data from abuses by employees and hackers. [Source]
--------